Through thick and thin: data commons, community and the struggle for collective data governance
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.71265/tk2x3d39Keywords:
data commons, collective data governance, community, policymaking, political philosophyAbstract
Collective data governance mechanisms such as data commons have recently gained traction in both theoretical and policy-oriented discussions as promising alternatives to the shortcomings of individualistic data protection and data markets. Many of these approaches centre around the idea of community as the key social institution overcoming these limitations. Yet, far less attention has been paid to the meaning, features and implications that the language of community can have for data commons.
This paper investigates the relationship between data commons and the community involved therein, with a focus on the kinds and features of such a community. It argues that analysing its key characteristics and moral-political affordances furnishes key implications for devising and implementing policies on collective data governance.
Downloads
References
Adalovelace Institute, ‘Participatory Data Stewardship: A Framework for Involving People in the Use of Data’ (2021) Adalovelace Institute Report www.adalovelaceinstitute.org/report/participatory-data-stewardship/ accessed 18 December 2024
Akbari Azadeh, ‘Situating Data: A Critique of Universalist Approaches to Data’ in Tess Osborne and Phil Jones (eds), A Research Agenda for Digital Geographies (Edward Elgar 2023)
Akbari Azadeh, ‘The Politics of Data Justice: Exit, Voice, or Rehumanisation?’ (2024) Information, Communication & Society 1
Benkler Yochai, The Wealth of Networks: How Social Production Transforms Markets and Freedom (Yale University Press 2006)
Brancaccio Francesco, ‘Appropriation, Common Property, the Inappropriable: Notes on the Law of the Common in Platform Capitalism’ (2019) 118 South Atlantic Quarterly 857
Broumas Antonios, Intellectual Commons and the Law: A Normative Theory for Commons-Based Peer Production (University of Westminster Press 2020)
Bühler Michael M and others, ‘Unlocking the Power of Digital Commons: Data Cooperatives as a Pathway for Data Sovereign, Innovative and Equitable Digital Communities’ 3 Digital 146
Calzada Igor, ‘Deciphering Smart City Citizenship: The Techno-Politics of Data and Urban Co-Operative Platforms’ (2018) 63 RIEV International Journal on Basque Studies 42
Calzati Stefano and Bastiaan van Loenen, ‘A Fourth Way to the Digital Transformation: The Data Republic as a Fair Data Ecosystem’ (2023) 5 Data & Policy 1
Carballa Smichowski Bruno, ‘Data as a Common in the Sharing Economy: A General Policy Proposal’ (2016) CEPN Document
de travail no. 2016-10 https://hal.science/hal-01386644/file/Carballa%20Smichowski%20Bruno%20(2016)%20-%20Data%20 as%20a%20common%20in%20the%20sharing%20economy%20a%20general%20policy%20proposal%20(CEPN%20WP).pdf accessed 6 January 2025
Carballa Smichowski Bruno, ‘Alternative Data Governance Models: Moving Beyond One-Size-Fits-All Solutions’ (2019) 54 Intereconomics 222
Cohen Julie E, Between Truth and Power: The Legal Constructions of Informational Capitalism (OUP 2019)
Cole Daniel H, ‘Learning from Lin: Lessons and Cautions from the Natural Commons for the Knowledge Commons’ in Brett M Frischmann, Michael J Madison and Katherine J Strandburg (eds), Governing Knowledge Commons (OUP 2014)
Couldry Nick and Ulises A Mejias, ‘Data Colonialism: Rethinking Big Data’s Relation to the Contemporary Subject’ (2019) 20 Television and New Media 336
Daniels Brigham, ‘Commons Storytelling: Tragedies, Comedies, and Tragicomedies’ in Blake Hudson, Jonathan Rosenbloom and Dan Cole (eds), Routledge Handbook of the Study of the Commons (Routledge 2019)
de Lange Michiel, ‘The Right to the Datafied City: Interfacing the Urban Data Commons’ in Paolo Cardullo, Cesare Di Feliciantonio and Rob Kitchin (eds), The Right to the Smart City (Emerald 2019)
De Moor Tine, ‘From Historical Institution to Pars pro Toto: The Commons and Their Revival in Historical Perspective’ in Blake Hudson, Jonathan Rosenbloom and Dan Cole, Routledge Handbook of the Study of the Commons (Routledge 2019)
de Souza Siddhart P, Hellen M Smith and Linnet Taylor, ‘Decolonial Data Law and Governance’ [2024] Technology and Regulation 1
Dean Mitchell, Governmentality: Power and Rule in Modern Society (2nd edn, Sage 2010)
Dencik Lina, ‘Rescuing’ Data Justice? Mobilising the Collective in Responses to Datafication’ [2025] Information, Communication & Society 1
Deshmukh Jaya and Alessandro Galtieri, ‘The Case for Data as a New Common Good: The Example of Water’ in Preeti Shroff-Mehta and others (eds), The Routledge Handbook of Global and Digital Governance Crossroads (Routledge 2024)
D’Ignazio Catherine and Lauren F Klein, Data Feminism (MIT Press 2020)
Dotson Taylor, Technically Together: Reconstructing Community in a Networked World (MIT Press 2017)
Ducuing Charlotte, ‘Beyond the Data Flow Paradigm: Governing Data Requires to Look beyond Data’ [2020] Technology and Regulation 57
Ducuing Charlotte, ‘Data as a Contested Commodity’ (2024) 24 Global Jurist 277
Ducuing Charlotte, Tommaso Fia and Gijs van Maanen, ‘Legislating on Data Commons: What It Should (Not) Be’ (Platform Cooperativism Consortium, 3 April 2024) https://platform.coop/blog/legislating-on-data-commons-what-it-should-not-be/ accessed 23 January 2024
Dulong de Rosnay Mélanie and Felix Stalder, ‘Digital Commons’ (2020) 9 Internet Policy Review 1
Dulong de Rosnay Mélanie, ‘Commonswashing – A Political Communication Struggle’ (2020) 2 Global Cooperation Research - A Quarterly Magazine 11
Jamie Duncan, ‘Data Protection Beyond Data Rights: Governing Data Production Through Collective Intermediaries’ (2023) 12 Internet Policy Review 1
Dunn John, Setting the People Free: The Story of Democracy (Atlantic Books 2005)
Seliem El-Sayed, Ilona Kickbusch and Barbara Prainsack, ‘Data Solidarity: Operationalising Public Value Through a Digital Tool’ (2025) 20 Global Public Health 1
Fia Tommaso, ‘An Alternative to Data Ownership: Managing Access to Non-Personal Data through the Commons’ (2021) 21 Global Jurist 181
Fia Tommaso, ‘Non-personal Data in the EU: Governance, Law and Justifications’ (CUP forthcoming)
Fia Tommaso, ‘Doing Justice to Justice in EU Data Law’ (Transformative Private Law Blog 24 October 2024) https://transformativeprivatelaw.com/doing-justice-to-justice-in-eu-data-law/ accessed 7 January 2025
Fia Tommaso, ‘Governance of Urban Data Commons as a Matter of Value Redistribution in the Smart City’ [2024] Sens Public 5
Fezer Jesko, ‘(Un)Social Community‘ (e-flux Architecture, June 2023) www.e-flux.com/ architecture/in-common/529686/un-social-community/ accessed 23 January 2025
Fischli Roberta and James Muldoon, ‘Empowering Digital Democracy’ (2024) 22 Perspectives on Politics 819
Frazer Elizabeth, The Problems of Communitarian Politics: Unity and Conflict (OUP 1999)
Fricker Miranda, Epistemic Injustice: Power and the Ethics of Knowing (OUP 2007)
Frischmann Brett M, Infrastructure: The Social Value of Shared Resources (OUP 2012)
Frischmann Brett M, ‘Two Enduring Lessons from Elinor Ostrom’ (2013) 9 Journal of Institutional Economics 387
Frischmann Brett M, Michael J Madison and Katherine J Strandburg, ‘Introduction: Governing Knowledge Commons’ in Brett M Frischmann, Michael J Madison and Katherine J Strandburg (eds), Governing Knowledge Commons (OUP 2014)
Fritsch Felix and others, ‘Challenges and Approaches to Scaling the Global Commons’ [2021] Frontiers in Blockchain 1
Geuns Jonathan van and Anna Brandusescu, ‘Shifting Power through Data Governance” (2020) Mozilla Paper https://assets.mofoprod.net/network/documents/ShiftingPower.pdf accessed 18 December 2024
Geuss Raymond, Not Thinking Like a Liberal (Harvard University Press 2022)
Graeber David, Fragments of an Anarchist Anthropology (Prickly Paradigm Press 2004)
Grossman Robert L, ‘Ten Lessons for Data Sharing with a Data Commons’ 10 Scientific Data 120
Hardt Michael and Antonio Negri, Assembly (OUP 2017)
Hardt Michael and Antonio Negri, Commonwealth (Harvard University Press 2009)
Haggart Blayne and Natasha Tusikov, The New Knowledge: Information, Data and the Remaking of Global Power (Rowman & Littlefield 2023)
Hesselink Martijn W, Justifying Contract in Europe: Political Philosophies of European Contract Law (OUP 2021)
Hesselink Martijn W, ‘Reconstituting the Code of Capital: Could a Progressive European Code of Private Law Help Us Reduce Inequality and Regain Democratic Control?’ (2022) 1 European Law Open 316
Hicks Jacqueline, ‘The Future of Data Ownership: An Uncommon Research Agenda’ (2023) 71 The Sociological Review 544
Hidalgo Enric S and others, ‘Co-creation of the Digital Democracy and Data Commons Manifesto: Alternative Sociotechnical Visions of Data’ (2024) 4 Open Research Europe 45
Ho Chih-hsing and Tyng-ruey Chuang, ‘Governance of Communal Data Sharing’ in Angela Daly, S Kate Devitt and Monique Mann (eds), Theory on Demand #29: Good Data (Institute of Network Cultures 2019)
Jeong Jong C and others, ‘Local Data Commons: The Sleeping Beauty in the Community of Data Commons’ (2022) 23 BMC Bioinformatics 386
Kaminski Margot E and Gianclaudio Malgieri, ‘Impacted Stakeholder Participation in AI and Data Governance’ (2024) Yale Journal of Law and Technology (forthcoming)
Kreiczer-Levy Shelly, ‘The Data Crowd as a Legal Stakeholder’ (2024) 44 Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 64
Krewer Jan, ‘From Open Access to Collective Governance Two Decades of Digital Commons Policies in the European Union’ (2025) Open Future and NGI Commons Paper https://openfuture.eu/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/250129_FromOpenAccesstoCollectiveGovernance. pdf accessed 29 April 2025
Kukutai Tahu and John Taylor, ‘Data Sovereignty for Indigenous Peoples: Current Practice and Future Needs’ in Tahu Kukutai and John Taylor (eds), Indigenous Data Sovereignty: Toward an Agenda (ANU Press 2016)
Kukutai Tahu and Donna Cormack, ‘‘Pushing the Space’: Data Sovereignty and Self-Determination in Aotearoa NZ’ in Maggie Walter and others (eds), Indigenous Data Sovereignty and Policy (Routledge 2021)
Kymlicka Will, Contemporary Political Philosophy: An Introduction (2nd edn, OUP 2002)
Latour Bruno, Reassembling the Social: An Introduction to Actor-Network-Theory (OUP 2005)
Loi Michele, Paul-Olivier Dehaye and Ernst Hafen, ‘Towards Rawlsian ‘Property-owning Democracy’ Through Personal Data Platform Cooperatives’ (2023) 26 Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 769
Lopez Solano Joao and others, Governing Data and Artificial Intelligence for All: Models for Sustainable and Just Data Governance (European Parliament 2022) https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/STUD/2022/729533/EPRS_STU(2022)729533_EN.pdf accessed 23 January 2025
Lovett Raymond and Carnell T Chosa, ‘Growing Pueblo Data Sovereignty’ in Maggie Walter and others (eds), Indigenous Data Sovereignty and Policy (Routledge 2021)
Maanen Gijs van, ‘From Communicating to Distributing: Open Government and Open Data in the Netherlands’ (PhD thesis, Tilburg University 2023)
Maanen Gijs van, Charlotte Ducuing and Tommaso Fia, ‘Data Commons’ (2024) 13 Internet Policy Review 1
Madison Michael J, Katherine Strandburg and Brett M Frischmann, ‘Knowledge Commons’ in Ben Depoorter, Peter Menell and David Schwartz (eds), Research Handbook on the Economics of Intellectual Property Law: Volume 2: Analytical Methods (Edward Elgar 2019)
Madison Michael J, ‘Tools for Data Governance’ [2020] Technology and Regulation 29
Madison Michael J and others, ‘Too Much of a Good Thing? A Governing Knowledge Commons Review of Abundance in Context’ (2022) 7 Frontiers in Research Metrics and Analytics 1
Madison Michael J, ‘Knowledge Commons Past, Present, and Future’ (2024) 28 Lewis & Clark Law Review 303
Michael J Madison, Brett M Frischmann and Katherine J Strandburg, ‘Knowledge Commons’ in Blake Hudson, Jonathan Rosenbloom and Dan Cole (eds), Routledge Handbook of the Study of the Commons (Routledge 2019)
Madison Michael J, Madelyn R Sanfilippo and Brett M Frischmann, ‘Smart Cities and Knowledge Commons’ in Brett M Frischmann, Michael J Madison and Madelyn Rose Sanfilippo (eds), Governing Smart Cities as Knowledge Commons (CUP 2023)
Marcucci Sara and others ‘Mapping and Comparing Data Governance Frameworks: A Benchmarking Exercise to Inform Global Data Governance Deliberations’ (2023) The GovLab Paper https://unsceb.org/sites/default/files/2023-05/Annex%201%20-%20Mapping%20and%20Comparing%20 Data%20Governance%20Frameworks.pdf accessed 23 January 2025
Marcucci Sara and others, ‘Informing the Global Data Future: Benchmarking Data Governance Frameworks’ (2023) 5 Data & Policy 1
Marglin Stephan A, The Dismal Science: How Thinking Like an Economist Undermines Community (Harvard University Press 2010)
Marres Noortje, ‘Articulation, or the Persistent Problem With Explanation’ (2024) 75 The British Journal of Sociology 354
Mattei Ugo and Alessandra Quarta, ‘Right to the City or Urban Commoning? Thoughts on the
Generative Transformation of Property Law’ (2015) 1 The Italian Law Journal 303
Micheli Marina and others, ‘Emerging Models of Data Governance in the Age of Datafication’ (2020) 7 Big Data & Society 1
Micheli Marina and others, Mapping the Landscape of Data Intermediaries: Emerging Models for More Inclusive Data Governance (Publications Office of the European Union 2023)
Miller Peter and Nikolas Rose, Governing the Present: Administering Economic, Social and Personal Life (Polity 2008)
Monterroso Iliana, Peter Cronkleton and Anne M Larson, ‘Commons, Indigenous Rights, and Governance’ in Blake Hudson, Jonathan Rosenbloom and Dan Cole, Routledge Handbook of the Study of the Commons (Routledge 2019)
Mozilla Insights, Jonathan van Geuns and Anna Brandusescu, ‘Shifting Power through Data Governance’ (2020) Mozilla Paper https://assets.mofoprod.net/network/documents/ShiftingPower.pdf accessed 18 December 2024
O’Neill Martin, ‘Power, Predistribution, and Social Justice’ (2020) 95 Philosophy 63
Open Data Institute, ‘Data Trusts: Lessons from Three Pilots’ (2019) https://theodi.org/article/odi-data-trusts-report/ accessed 18 December 2024
Ostrom Elinor, Understanding Institutional Diversity (Princeton University Press 2005)
Ostrom Elinor, Marco A Janssen and John M Anderies, ‘Going beyond Panaceas’ (2007) 104 Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 15176
Ottolia Andrea and Cristiana Sappa, ‘A Topography of Data Commons: From Regulation to Private Dynamism’ (2022) 71 GRUR International 335
Paine Sarah-Jane and others, ‘Kaupapa Māori-Informed Approaches to Support Data Rights and Self-Determination’ in Maggie Walter and others (eds), Indigenous Data Sovereignty and Policy (Routledge 2021)
Potts Jason and others, ‘Profiting from Data Commons: Theory, Evidence, and Strategy Implications’ (2024) 9 Strategy Science 1
Prainsack Barbara, ‘The Roots of Neglect: Towards a Sociology of Non-Imagination’ (2022) 13 Tecnoscienza: Italian Journal of Science & Technology Studies 13
Prainsack Barbara and others, ‘Data Solidarity’ (2022) Governing Health Futures White Paper https://www.governinghealthfutures2030.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/DataSolidarity.pdf accessed 23 January 2025
Ptak Thomas and others, ‘Rethinking Community: Analyzing the Landscape of Community Solar through the Community-Place Nexus’ (2018) 31 The Electricity Journal 46
Purtova Nadezhda and Gijs Van Maanen, ‘Data as an Economic Good, Data as a Commons, and Data Governance’ (2024) 16 Law, Innovation and Technology 1.
Purtova Nadezhda and Bryce Clayton Newell, ‘Against Data Fixation: Why 'Data' Fails as a Regulatory Target for Data Protection Law and What to Do About It’ (2024) SSRN Paper http:// dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4878564 accessed 18 December 2024
Quarta Alessandra and Tomaso Ferrando, ‘Italian Property Outlaws: From the Theory of the Commons to the Praxis of Occupation’ (2015) 15 Global Jurist 261
Raghunath Preeti ‘Critical Data Governance: A Southern Standpoint to the Study and Practice of Data’ [2024] Technology and Regulation 37
Rose Nikolas, Powers of Freedom: Reframing Political Thought (CUP 1999)
Ruhaak Anouk and others, ‘A Practical Framework for Applying Ostrom’s Principles to Data Commons Governance’ (2021) Mozilla Foundation https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/blog/a-practical-framework-for-applying-ostroms- principles-to-data-commons-governance/ accessed 23 January 2025
Sanfilippo Madelyn R and Brett M Frischmann, ‘Beyond Design Principles’ in Brett M Frischmann, Michael J Madison and Madelyn Rose Sanfilippo (eds), Governing Smart Cities as Knowledge Commons (CUP 2023)
Scassa Teresa, ‘Designing Data Governance for Data Sharing: Lessons from Sidewalk Toronto’ [2020] Technology and Regulation 44
Shkabatur Jennifer, ‘The Global Commons of Data’ (2019) 22 Stanford Technology Law Review 354
Shultz Sébastien, ‘Moving from Coproduction to Commonization of Digital Public Goods and Services’ (2025) 85 Public Administration Review 60
Siffels Lotje E and Tamar Sharon, ‘Where Technology Leads, the Problems Follow. Technosolutionism and the Dutch Contact Tracing App’ (2024) 37 Philosophy and Technology 125
Singleton Sara and Michael Taylor, ‘Common Property, Collective Action and Community’ (1992) 4 Journal of Theoretical Politics 309
Singh Aditya and Divij Joshi, ‘The Histories, Practices and Policies of Community Data Governance in the Global South’ (2023) IT For Change Paper https://itforchange.net/sites/default/files/2403/ITFC_UDVC_Community%20Data%20Governance.pdf accessed 28 May 2025
Smith Diane E, ‘Governing Data and Data for Governance: The Everyday Practice of Indigenous Sovereignty’ in Tahu Kukutai and John Taylor (eds), Indigenous Data Sovereignty: Toward an Agenda (ANU Press 2016)
Sporle Andrew and Carnell T Hudson, ‘Indigenous Data and Policy in Aotearoa New Zealand’ in Maggie Walter and others (eds), Indigenous Data Sovereignty and Policy (Routledge 2021)
Stalder Felix, The Digital Condition (Polity Press 2018)
Tarkowski Alek and Jan Zygmuntowski, ‘Data Commons Primer: Democratising the Information Society’ (2022) Open Future Paper 26
Tarkowski Alek and Zuzanna Warso, ‘Commons-Based Data Set Governance for AI’ (2024) Open Future Paper https://openfuture.eu/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/240325_Commons_Based_Data_Set_Governance_for_AI.pdfaccessed 6 January 2025
Vaccaro Ismael and Oriol Beltran, ‘What Do We Mean by ‘the Commons?’ An Examination of Conceptual Blurring Over Time’ (2019) 47 Human Ecology 33
Valente Jonas CL and Rafael Grohmann, 'Critical Data Studies with Latin America: Theorizing Beyond Data Colonialism' (2024) 11 Big Data & Society 1
Verhulst Stefaan G, Hannah Chafetz and Andrew Zahuranec, ‘‘Data Commons’: Under Threat by or The Solution for a Generative AI Era? Rethinking Data Access and Reuse’ (Data & Policy Blog, 30 May 2024) https://medium.com/data-policy/data-commons-under-threat-by-or-the-solution-for-a-generative-ai-era-rethinking-9193e35f85e6 accessed 23 January 2025
Viljoen Salomé, ‘A Relational Theory of Data Governance’ (2021) 131 Yale Law Journal 573
Viljoen Salomé, ‘Informationalism Beyond Managerialism’ (2023) 86 Law and Contemporary Problems 257
Wong Janis, Tristan Henderson and Kirstie Ball, ‘Data Protection for the Common Good: Developing a Framework for a Data Protection-Focused Data Commons’ (2022) 4 Data & Policy 1
Walter Maggie and Stephanie Russo Carroll, ‘Indigenous Data Sovereignty, Governance and the Link to Indigenous Policy’ in Maggie Walter and others (eds), Indigenous Data Sovereignty and Policy (Routledge 2021)
Whyte Jessica, The Morals of the Market: Human Rights and the Rise of Neoliberalism (Verso 2019)
Wu Dan and others, ‘How Data Governance Technologies Can Democratize Data Sharing for Community Well-Being’ 3 Data & Policy e14
Zygmuntowski Jan, Laura Zoboli and Paul F Nemitz, ‘Embedding European Values in Data Governance: A Case for Public Data Commons’ (2021) 10 Internet Policy Review 1
Downloads
Published
Versions
- 02-06-2025 (2)
- 02-06-2025 (1)
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Tommaso Fia, Gijs van Maanen
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
How to Cite
Funding data
-
European Research Council
Grant numbers 716971 -
Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft
Grant numbers 390727645
